Trinidad Chicken Pelau Dish

Trinidad Chicken Pelau is a legendary one-pot meal from my island kitchen that always draws people to the table. Juicy caramelized chicken, tender rice, creamy pigeon peas, fresh herbs, and a hint of sweet coconut milk combine for a comforting dish with layers of flavor. This is the recipe I make when I want to transport my home to Trinidad for a night.

I started making pelau in college to cure homesickness and now it is the most requested dish at my family gatherings. The way it fills the kitchen with aromas reminds me of sunny Caribbean afternoons at grandma’s house.

Ingredients

• Chicken bite-sized pieces: Choose a whole chicken or just legs and thighs for best flavor and tender meat

• Green seasoning: Caribbean flavor powerhouse made with blended herbs Scotch bonnet and garlic Use homemade if you can for freshness

• Brown sugar: This adds the signature deep caramel flavor Look for dark or raw sugar

• Parboiled rice: Holds its shape and does not get mushy Choose a brand with firm long grains

• Chopped onion: Lends savory sweetness to round out the flavor

• Chopped pimento pepper: Adds mild heat and authentic taste Use fresh Trinidadian pimento if available

• Garlic: For depth and aroma Choose fat fresh cloves

• Chopped parsley: Brightens the pot Use flat-leaf for best flavor

• Chopped culantro: Gives a bold earthy note Look in Latin or Caribbean markets

• Chopped ginger: Brings warmth and a lightly spicy undertone Use a heavy knob

• Cubed pumpkin: Adds subtle sweetness and boosts the texture Look for orange-fleshed Caribbean varieties

• Canned pigeon peas: Classic pelau ingredient Found in the international section Choose brands with peas packed in water

• Salt: To enhance all the other flavors Use kosher or sea salt for clean taste

• Coconut milk: Makes it rich creamy and slightly sweet Select the full-fat version for best results

• Hot water: Helps cook the rice and brings everything together

• Tomato ketchup: Adds tang and roundness Choose low sugar for best balance

• Black pepper: Freshly cracked gives a mild punch

Step-by-Step Instructions

Prep and Marinate the Chicken:

Rinse your chicken pieces well and pat them dry thoroughly. Season generously with green seasoning and massage the flavors in. Give it at least thirty minutes to marinate or overnight if possible for the richest taste

Caramelize the Sugar:

Place a heavy-bottomed pot over medium heat and sprinkle brown sugar evenly in the base. Let the sugar melt slowly without stirring. Watch for a deep amber color and bubbles that signal caramelization. This is what flavors the chicken

Brown the Chicken:

Right when the sugar is perfectly caramelized add the seasoned chicken. Toss to coat every piece. Sear for about two to five minutes turning so each side is colored and the aroma fills your kitchen

Add Peas and Cook Down:

Mix in the drained pigeon peas. Cook this mixture for five minutes letting the peas soak up the caramel and seasoning. The bottom should develop a flavorful brown glaze

Mix in Vegetables and Herbs:

Now add the rice pumpkin pimento pepper onion garlic ginger parsley culantro salt black pepper and ketchup. Take time to mix everything thoroughly so the seasoning is even from bite to bite

Pour and Simmer:

Pour hot water over the whole pot before adding coconut milk. Stir very well scraping the bottom to release every bit of flavor

Finish and Steam:

Raise the heat to bring the mixture to a lively boil. Quickly lower to a gentle simmer and cover tightly. Leave it undisturbed until the rice is tender and most of the liquid has been absorbed

Taste and Adjust Seasoning:

Before serving lift the lid and fluff the rice gently with a fork. Taste for salt and black pepper balance and adjust if needed

Pin

My kids always pick out the biggest bites of caramelized chicken and argue over the edges where the rice is golden. The coconut milk is my favorite touch because it makes the whole dish extra creamy and comforting especially on cool nights.

Storage Tips

Pelau keeps beautifully in the fridge for up to three days. Let it cool completely before transferring to an airtight container. Reheat gently on the stove with a splash of water or coconut milk to restore steam and freshness without drying out the rice. This meal also freezes well for future cravings.

Ingredient Substitutions

If you cannot find pigeon peas use black-eyed peas or even kidney beans for a similar bite. No culantro Swap in cilantro. For a spicier pelau add a small Scotch bonnet pepper whole but do not break it unless you want extra heat. Pumpkin can be swapped for butternut squash.

Serving Suggestions

Serve pelau hot from the pot with a side of creamy coleslaw or sliced ripe avocado. I love topping mine with a quick cucumber salad or pickled onions crunch and tang always pair well with the comfort of warm rice.

Pin

Cultural and Historical Context

Chicken pelau is the beating heart of Caribbean gatherings from family Sundays to big festivals. Its roots are African Indian and Spanish and each family has a signature style. The secret step is the caramelized sugar which sets Trinidad pelau apart from other rice dishes around the world and gives it its unmistakable warmth.

Recipe FAQs

→ What is the key to getting the right color for Trinidad pelau?

The secret lies in carefully caramelizing the brown sugar until deep amber before adding the chicken. This gives rich color and a subtle, smoky sweetness.

→ Which rice works best for pelau?

Parboiled rice is traditional, as it holds its shape and absorbs flavors well throughout simmering without becoming mushy.

→ Can I substitute fresh pigeon peas with canned?

Canned pigeon peas are a convenient and widely used option; simply drain and rinse before adding to the pot.

→ How do I achieve a firmer texture?

Use less liquid (closer to 1½ cups each of coconut milk and water) and avoid overcooking to keep rice and chicken more separate and drier.

→ Is green seasoning necessary?

Green seasoning is a cornerstone of Trinidadian cooking, infusing the chicken with herbal and aromatic flavors. It is highly recommended.

→ Can this dish be made vegetarian?

Yes, replace chicken with extra pumpkin or your preferred beans and add more vegetables for a hearty vegetarian version.