Pin
These grab-and-go mini banana cream pies have turned into my go-to lifesaver when friends pop over unexpectedly or when it's too darn hot to bake. The mix of crunchy graham base and smooth banana filling makes cute personal treats that'll wow your guests without you breaking a sweat.
I whipped up these mini pies during an awful summer heat spell when my kid wanted something fancy for her birthday but turning on the oven wasn't happening. They've stuck around as our warm-weather favorite, with everyone asking for them at family cookouts.
What You'll Need
- Graham cracker crumbs make your own instead of buying pre-made and warm them in a pan for extra taste
- Melted butter pick unsalted so you can manage how sweet everything turns out
- Sugar plain white works in the crust but powdered makes fluffier whipped cream
- Instant banana cream pudding mix the clever shortcut that makes these so quick
- Cold milk grab whole milk for the creamiest result as the fat helps it set up right
- Heavy cream needs to be super cold from the fridge for best fluffing
- Powdered sugar keeps your whipped cream standing tall without collapsing
- Vanilla extract real stuff works way better than the fake kind
- Ripe bananas go for ones with tiny brown freckles for sweetness without mush
- Whipped cream homemade beats the stuff from a can any day
- Honey just a tiny drizzle adds fanciness and extra flavor
Getting Started
- Make your base
- Mix graham crumbs with melted butter and sugar until every bit gets wet. It should stick when you squeeze it but not feel soaked. Push it down hard with a measuring cup into muffin tins, covering the bottom and halfway up the sides. Let it sit in the fridge for an hour to get firm.
- Fix the pudding
- Beat the banana pudding mix with cold milk for two full minutes. Don't worry if it looks thin at first - it'll thicken as you stir. Cool it in the fridge for exactly 5 minutes so it thickens a bit but stays easy to work with. If it gets too cold, it'll be too stiff to mix properly.
- Get your cream ready
- In another bowl with clean beaters, whip your cold cream starting slow and getting faster. When it starts to form soft peaks, add the powdered sugar and vanilla. Keep whipping until it stands up straight when you lift the beaters. Don't go too far or you'll end up with butter!
- Build the fluffy filling
- Carefully fold half your whipped cream into the pudding using a rubber spatula. Cut down the middle and scoop around and up, turning the bowl as you go. Keep going until no streaks show but stop before you knock all the air out. This gentle mixing keeps it nice and fluffy.
- Put it all together
- Scoop your banana fluff into each cold crust, filling almost to the top. Smooth it out with a flat knife. Drop a big spoonful of leftover whipped cream in the middle of each pie, making a little mound. Right before you serve them, arrange banana slices in a pretty pattern and add a tiny drizzle of honey over top.
Pin
Using instant pudding might seem like cheating but it gives these mini pies just the right texture. I figured this out after trying three times to make fancy homemade cream that either stayed too runny or got way too heavy for these little treats.
Tasty Twists
These little pies can be changed up lots of ways. Try using chocolate cookies for the crust to switch things up. Spreading a thin layer of melted chocolate between the crust and filling keeps the bottom crispy longer, which really helps if you're making them a day early.
Want something more exotic? Swap half the milk with coconut cream and sprinkle toasted coconut on top. The light coconut flavor works great with banana and adds a nice crunch too.
Keeping Them Fresh
These mini pies stay good in the fridge for up to three days, though the bananas on top will turn brown after day one. For the freshest look, add banana slices right before serving. You can also freeze the pies without banana toppings for up to a month. Let them thaw in the fridge overnight and they'll bounce back nicely.
You'll need to cover these pies but it's tricky with the whipped cream on top. Small plastic containers work great, but if you don't have any, stick toothpicks around each pie and loosely lay plastic wrap over them so you don't smash your pretty decorations.
Serving Suggestions
These mini banana treats really shine with the right partners. Try adding a tiny scoop of coffee or caramel ice cream on the side for a fancy dessert plate. At brunch, serve them with a little shot of cold brew or a small glass of bourbon-flavored milk for a grown-up touch.
Pin
Recipe FAQs
- → How long will these tiny banana pies stay good?
You'll want to eat these little treats within 1-2 days. The banana slices start turning brown after that. Keep them in your fridge with a cover to keep them fresh.
- → Can I get these ready before my party?
Absolutely! You can fix the cookie crusts and the pudding mix up to 2 days early. Just wait to put the banana slices on until you're almost ready to serve them so they don't turn brown.
- → What else can I use if I don't have graham crackers?
No graham crackers? No problem! Try vanilla wafers, digestive cookies, or even ginger snaps for your crust. Just crush them up good and follow the same steps.
- → How do I get the pies out without making a mess?
Make sure they're super cold first - at least 3 hours in the fridge. Then run a butter knife around the edges and lift them out carefully. Using paper or silicone cupcake liners makes this way easier.
- → Can I skip the pudding mix and use real bananas?
Sure thing! Instead of boxed pudding, try 2 cups of vanilla pudding mixed with 1/2 cup of mashed ripe bananas. This gives you a more real banana taste in every bite.
- → What's the trick to stop bananas from turning brown?
Just brush your banana slices with a bit of lemon juice or pineapple juice before you put them on top. This stops them from turning brown and keeps them looking fresh longer.